Scareclaw Kashtira + Hope Harbinger glitched interaction

  1. Bug description
    Hi, I came up with a glitched interaction between Scareclaw Kashtira and Number 38: Hope Harbinger Dragon Titanic Galaxy (and Blue-Eyes Jet Dragon may be involved).

  2. Bug reproduction steps

    Spoiler

    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

    Step 1 : I was in the gamestate in screenshot 1: I had a Scareclaw Kashtira in defense position and other monsters. My opponent had a Hope Harbinger in Attack position, a 0/0 Amorphage Sloth in Defense (summoned by Hieratic Seal) and a Blue-Eyes Jet Dragon in the GY.

    Step 2: I attack Hope Harbinger with Scareclaw Kashtira. Hope Harbinger has the “negated” symbol on it. (screenshot 2)

    Step 3: Damage calculation happens, I take 400 damage, Scareclaw Kashtira goes to GY.

    Step 4: Blue-Eyes Jet Dragon triggers. (screenshot 3)

    Step 5: After the start of the resolution and before Jet is special summoned, there is one replay click in which Hope Harbinger lost the “negated” symbol.(screenshot 4)

    Step 6: Jet is summoned, the battle ends. At this point Hope Harbinger is no longer negated. (screenshot 5) When I try to attack Sloth with Reichheart after this, Hope Harbinger activates its effect to redirect the attack and it resolves, I crash Reichheart and I lose.

  3. Screenshot OR error code

  1. Expected behavior
    Because Hope Harbinger battled Scareclaw Kashtira, it is supposed to stay negated until the end of the turn. Scareclaw Kashtira is not required to stay on the field for this to take place.

  2. What OS are you using
    Windows 10

This effect is (continuously) applied to monsters that battle your “Kashtira” or “Scareclaw” monsters. If this card’s effect stops applying (such as because it is no longer face-up in the Monster Zone, or its effects are negated), the opponent’s monster’s effects stop being negated.
https://db.ygorganization.com/card#18152

1 Like

Okay thanks
I was given the wrong ruling in paper play then

Danger is correct.

If you wanted to play this out closer to how you were expecting, you would need to attack hope harbringe with Light heart, negating it and losing the light heart to battle, then declare attack with Scareclaw Kashtira on the sloth.

This would work the way you expected.

This topic was automatically closed 24 hours after the last reply. New replies are no longer allowed.