Error with the resolution of Madolche Chateau

YGO Omega Bugs
1

  1. Bug description
    The activation of Madolche Chateau does not prompt the trigger effect of Madolche Puddingcess Chocolat-A-La-Mode

  2. Bug reproduction steps

    Zone placement does not matter for this combo, although typically no monsters are summoned to the Extra Monster Zone.
    1. Normal summon Madolche Anjelly, activate its effect, special summon Madolche Petingcessoeur.
    2. Activate Petingcessoeur's effect on summon, special summong Madolche Puddingcess from the deck.
    3. Overlay Petingcessoeur and Puddingcess for Madolche Glassouffle.
    4. Activate Glassouffle's quick effect and detach Petingcessoeur targeting Glassouffle, but do not activate the trigger effect of Glassouffle afterwards.
    5. Summon Madolche Puddingcess Chocolat-A-La-Mode using Glassouffle as material.
    6. Activate the effect of Chocolat, target either Petingcessoeur or Anjelly (doesn't matter which), shuffle it into the deck.
    7. Activate the trigger effect of Chocolat and detach Glassouffle, special summon Madolche Hootcake from the deck.
    8. Activate Hootcake's effect on field, target Glassouffle in the GY, banish it, then special summon Madolche Messengelato from the deck.
    9. Activate Messengelato's on-summon effect, add Madolche Chateau from deck to hand.
    10. Activate Chateau from hand, shuffling back the last Madolche monster in the GY (either the Petingcessoeur or the Anjelly, whichever was not shuffled back off of Chocolat previously).

    Spoiler

    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

  3. Screenshot OR error code

image
image1280Ă—941 172 KB

  1. Expected behavior
    Madolche Puddingcess Chocolat-A-La-Mode does not have a once-per-turn limitation on its trigger effect, which means any instance in which a Madolche card is shuffled into the main deck should prompt its effect to special summon a Madolche monster from the deck, so long as Madolche Puddingcess is one of Chocolat's overlay units. Usually the way the combo proceeds from there is that you would summon a second Madolche Messengelato from the deck to get another Madolche spell or trap. However, something about the way Chateau resolves in Yugioh Omega does not prompt the trigger effect. Moreover, the duel log does not list which cards are shuffled back when Madolche Chateau resolves. I consulted a judge prior to reporting this incident to make sure the rulings on this are the same in TCG and OCG, as I usually perform this line in Master Duel, which typically runs by OCG rulings. Thank you in advance, and keep up the great work.

  2. What OS are you using
    Windows-10

1 Like
2

Any update on this? Madolche has been unplayable for quite a while now.

3

That effect looks to be erroneously once-per-Chain. I’ll look into it.

In the meantime, please try this again online.

4

@Epsi Try this again online; here’s why she’s Once-per-Chain, Bing-translated from Japanese:

■ (2): If this card uses “Maldolche Puddingcess” as the X material, when the “Madolce” card from your graveyard returns to the deck, you can remove one of the X material of this card and activate it. The monster effect of special summoning one “Madolce” monster from the deck with a front attack display or a back defensive display is an inducing effect. (It is not an effect that takes the target.) When activating this effect, you will remove one of the Exies material on this card as a cost. This effect can be activated multiple times in one turn, but not multiple times on the same chain. Also, it cannot be activated in the damage step.