Elemental HERO Spirit of Neos battle protection

  1. Bug description
    On other automated platforms like EDOpro and Master Duel the battle protection from Spirit of Neos lingers even if the card’s effects are negated by something like Skill Drain, on YGO Omega it loses this battle protection if the effect is negated though. I know it’s a weird ruling space, because cards like Destrudo and Duke Shade don’t linger but cards like Eldlich do. Should Master Duel be taken as the proper ruling for paper play because it’s an official simulator?

  2. Bug reproduction steps
    In the replay I summon Spirit of Neos by its own effect in response to an attack then activate Skill Drain.

    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

  3. Screenshot OR error code

  4. Expected behavior
    I thought that Spirit of Neos would keep its battle protection under Skill Drain, instead it was destroyed by battle.

  5. What OS are you using
    Windows 10

1 Like

Came on here to report the exact same thing. Just lost a game because of it.

Try this again @hax