Bug description
[Describe what the bug is in your own words.]
When “crystal beast”-monsters get destroyed (by battle or effect), they don’t move to the GY, the rather move to the spell/trap zone as a continous spell. So far, everything works as intended!
But when I duelled my friend, who played a crystal beast-deck the following happend:
He had one Beast (“Crystal Beast Amber Mammoth”) in his spell/trap zone and one in his monster-zone (“Crystal Beast Topaz Tiger”). I activated “Smashing Ground”, to pop his Tiger. “Smashing Ground” targets the opponents monster with the highest DEF. The effect targeted the “Spell”-Mammoth instead of the “Monster”-Tiger. Propably because Mammoth has more DEF and normally would be the right target, but in this case Mammoth wasn’t suppose to count as a Monster-Card, but a Spell-Card.
But this isn’t where it ends!
My friend then got the option, to either move Mammoth to the GY OR to move it to the backrow. This is what usually happens, when a “crystall beast”-monster get’s destroyed, even though it wasn’t suppose to happen in this case.
Just to try it out, he did choose the option, to mome Mammoth to the backrow, even though it already was in the backrow. That crashed the game for both of us.
So the problem was that:
Smashing Ground targeted the Crystal Beast in the Backrow, when it shouldn’t have.
The simulator gave the prompt again, to move the Crystal Beast to the Backrow, even though it was already there. Trying to move it to the Backrow again will crash the game.
We ofc redid the duel, but this time, when we were in the exact same situation (Mammoth in Backrow, Tiger in Frontrow and me using Smashing Ground), he this time chose to put Mammoth in the GY. That worked (but Mammoth wasn’t suppose to be targeted anyway)
Bug reproduction steps
[Write the exact steps to reproduce the bug. Provide a replay code if you can. You can attach replay codes, or use a pastebin link or you can even use a spoiler tag using]
Spoiler
your replay code
Crystal Beast in Spell/Trap Zone. Another Crystal Beast in Monster-Zone. Opponent uses a removal spell, that auto-targets something. In my case: Smashing ground, targeting the Monster with the highest def, which was theoretically the Crystal Beast in the Backrow. (Might also work with “Fissure” or “Hammer Shot”: Didn’t try it, sorry :c)
When you activated the first Bug: Use the prompt-option to put your “already in Backrow Crystal Beast” in the Backrow. Game should crash, or at least the duel/room.
Screenshot OR error code
n.v.
Expected behavior
[Tell us what should have happened when the bug occurred.]
My “Smashing Ground” should have hit the Crystal Beast, that was face-up in the Monster-Zone, not the one that was face-up in the Spell/Trap-Zone. Because Crystal Beasts in the Spell/Trap-Zone are suppose to be continous spells. The prompt to move the Crystal Beast also shouldn’t have appeared in this situation, because the Monster already was in the backrow.
Maybe the prompt should re-check the position of the card itself? idk
At this point I want to say, that I was able to remove the backrow Crystal Beasts with effects, that are meant to remove Spell/Traps without any issue. No prompt appearing, where it shouldn’t or anything!
Cards like Heavy Storm or Raigeki Break work fine! My friend was also able to use his crystal beasts as tribute to summon “Hamon, Lord of Striking Thunder”, which needs three face-up continous spell-cards on your side fo the field as tribute. The “continous spell”-state seemed to have worked. But maybe “Smashing Ground” just looks for DEF-Values, without checking what kind of card it is targeting (propably because of the Trap-Card-Monsters. BUT they also shouldn’t be targeted while they are face-up in the Spell/Trap-Zone).
At this point I ALSO want to take the time to thank you, for making this simulator! My friend and me are having a blast!!
What OS are you using
[Windows-10 / Linux / Android]
Windows-Version! I’m on Windows 11 now, but when we had the duel, I was still on Windows 10. Idk what he is on though …
Hello, we searched for the replay!
I wasn’t 100% on with my describtion, but imo it doesn’t change what happened and what might have been causing the error.
But you are the person to judge that:
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
